Butterscotch pudding

 You can make butterscotch pudding at home with a buttery flavor and a splash of scotch for a true butterscotch flavor. It’s easy and doesn’t take long! It’s just like making a custard, thickened with a little cornstarch.

How do you feel about pudding? Love it? Hate it? I get the impression that everybody likes pudding, but I’m actually not quite sure how I feel about the dessert. Growing up, we didn’t eat pudding. We never went to school with a pudding cup in our lunchboxes. I usually had apple sauce instead of pudding, or yogurt, specifically the fruit-on-the-bottom kind that is so hard to find lately. We never had pudding and I don’t remember ever being upset over it’s absence in my lunchbox.


Pudding is one of those foods that I wanted to eat, just as all the other kids were, but then when faced with a cup of the stuff, it kind of grossed me out. I think it was the texture of the pudding in pudding cups. I was the same way with jello. I remember a couple times, I got my mom to buy a box of jello mix, then she’d make it, and it would sit, untouched, in the fridge. Again, jello was one of those foods that, in theory, I wanted to like/eat like my friends did but, in practice, it just wasn’t as tasty as I expected. Plus it’s freakishly jiggly and the bright, unnatural colors freak me out. That stuff belongs in a lab, not on my dessert spoon.


True to temptation, I saw the butterscotch pudding in this month’s Bon Appétit magazine, and immediately wanted to give pudding one more chance. After all, the homemade kind can’t be anything like store-bought pudding. I was right. I guess I’m a pudding snob and only eat it when it’s homemade.

This is nothing like pudding-cup style pudding. This recipe is obviously tongue-coatingly richer because it is made with whole milk, lots of cream and browned butter (my favorite of all butters). It’s also thicker from the combined power of egg yolks and cornstarch. This recipe yields a pudding with a mellow butterscotch flavor that I really enjoyed. I expected it to be overly sweet, but it isn’t, especially if you add a dollop of crème fraîche. I served this dessert with homemade gingersnaps, but you could crumble graham crackers over top, or even just sprinkle generously with graham cracker crumbs.



Butterscotch pudding

You can make butterscotch pudding at home from scratch. Butterscotch pudding is really easy to make and is quite quick to prepare.
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 35 minutes
Servings 9
Calories 433kcal
Author Janice


  • 58 grams unsalted butter 1/4 cup
  • 1 vanilla bean split lengthwise
  • 150 grams light brown sugar 3/4 cup
  • 625 mL whipping cream (35 % fat) 2 1/2 cups
  • 250 mL whole milk (3.25 % fat) 1 cup, 3.25% fat
  • 1 tablespoon scotch I actually used Jack Daniel’s whiskey
  • 1/4 tsp fine kosher salt
  • 6 large egg yolks
  • 29 grams cornstarch 1/4 cup
  • 3 tbsp granulated sugar
  • crème fraîche and gingersnaps to serve optional but highly recommended!


  • Place the butter in a medium saucepan, then scrape the vanilla bean seeds and add them to the pan along with the bean. Swirl the pan, over medium-high, until the butter browns and smells nutty. Pull the pan off the heat.
  • Add the brown sugar, milk, heavy cream, whiskey, and the salt to the saucepan. Heat the mixture over medium-high heat, whisking occasionally to dissolve the sugar.
  • Meanwhile, in a medium bowl, beat together the yolks, cornstarch and granulated sugar until it has lightened in color a little.
  • When the cream mixture is steamy and just about to boil, take it off the heat and pour it over the yolk mixture, whisking the yolks as you pour. When all the cream mixture is whisked into the yolk mixture, strain it back into the saucepan and cook over medium heat, with constant whisking til the mixture begins to boil.
  • Boil the mixture for 1 full minute, whisking constantly, then remove from heat. Blitz the mixture with a handblender to smooth it out (this isn’t absolutely necessary but ensures a silky smooth texture).
  • Divide the pudding between 9 small jars or ramekins (I used 125 mL mason jars). I placed plastic wrap over the surface of each to avoid “pudding skin” but you don’t have to. Refrigerate for several hours to chill completely, or overnight.
  • Serve with a dollop of crème fraîche and crumbled gingersnaps.
Tried this recipe?Mention @kitchenhealssoul or tag #kitchenhealssoul!


Calories: 433kcal

butterscotch, caramel

7 Responses to Butterscotch pudding

  1. Zoe March 6, 2013 at 1:46 AM #

    Hi Janice,

    I love the way you made these puddings in mason jars. They look really cute to eat.

    This is my first time visiting your blog and I’m really amazed with some of your recipe comparisons. You are so brilliant doing this. I’m now your latest blog and twitter follower. Cheers!


    • Janice Lawandi March 6, 2013 at 1:42 PM #

      I think recipe comparisons are the best kind of experiments 😉 Thank you for your lovely comment and for following, Zoe!

  2. Aimee @ Simple Bites March 6, 2013 at 11:58 PM #

    I’ll only eat homemade pudding as well, but my boring repertoire only includes chocolate and vanilla. Thanks for the inspiration to remedy that.

  3. Peanut March 8, 2013 at 8:08 PM #

    Hi! ireally like your blog and i’m following from florwnce 🙂
    i’ve decided to give you a “reward” for your blog, if you like, come and get it!


  1. Tapioca pudding with fresh strawberries & a giveaway with Ricardo - May 6, 2017

    […] pudding is a classic, as is butterscotch, in my books. This tapioca pudding recipe from Ricardo is more like a tapioca crème anglaise that […]

  2. Rhubarb pudding cake | Kitchen Heals SoulKitchen Heals Soul - May 29, 2020

    […] pudding is more of an egg-thickened or starch-thickened custard, like butterscotch pudding thickened with egg yolks and cornstarch which gels the milk in the recipe, or vanilla bean tapioca […]

  3. Dictionary of French baking terms and translations | Kitchen Heals SoulKitchen Heals Soul - June 17, 2020

    […] de crème is an egg-thickened pudding, unlike American puddings, like butterscotch pudding, that is thickened with cornstarch. Pots de crème are often made with chocolate which makes them […]

Leave a Reply

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.